You Can't Be Responsible for Everyone Else's Job: dealing with difficult real estate agents


I've worked with agents who made difficult transactions easier and agents who made perfectly manageable transactions almost impossible. After 20 years in real estate, I can tell you that the agent on the other side matters a lot more than most new agents realize. You can prepare your clients, negotiate a solid contract, stay ahead of deadlines, and do everything you're supposed to do. Then you find yourself dealing with another agent who doesn't return calls, makes assumptions, or turns a fairly routine disagreement into a personal argument. It's difficult dealing with difficult real estate agents.
I've had my share of those.
I remember one inspection negotiation that got particularly contentious. The other agent became upset enough to call me a name I won't repeat here. At that point, I could have gotten defensive and argued right back. I certainly wasn't happy about it. Instead of continuing the argument, I asked the agent to walk me through which inspection items were actually concerning the seller. Once we stopped arguing about the entire report and focused on the specific repairs, we could have a more productive conversation.
Sometimes the other agent is frustrated. Sometimes they're inexperienced. Sometimes they're under pressure from a client, and you're getting the brunt of it. None of that excuses unprofessional behavior, but understanding what's happening can help you figure out what to do next.
And occasionally, the problem isn't that someone is being difficult. It's that they're absolutely convinced they know the answer. I once had an agent tell me that a seller wouldn't consider an offer my buyer wanted to make. The agent was quite certain about it.
I submitted the offer anyway.
The seller countered, and we ended up under contract. I think about that transaction because it would have been easy to take the other agent's word for it. After all, they're the one communicating with the seller. They should have a pretty good idea of what their client wants. But having a pretty good idea isn't the same as knowing what someone will actually decide when an offer is in front of them.
That's something I've become much more aware of as I've gained experience. I listen to what other agents tell me, but I also recognize that they're working with their own clients, their own assumptions, and sometimes their own frustrations.
My responsibility is to my client. I can't let another agent's opinion make a decision for them.
I also can't control how that agent communicates, how prepared they are, or whether they approach the transaction with the same level of professionalism I expect from myself. That's probably one of the harder adjustments for newer agents. You spend so much time learning how to do everything correctly that it's frustrating to discover how much depends on people whose work you can't manage.
I've learned to be more thorough about the things I can verify and more careful about the assumptions I make. I've also learned that some conversations aren't going to be pleasant, no matter how professionally I handle them. I'm still going to make the call, ask the question, submit the offer, and do what I believe is right for my client. And when something goes wrong, I'll look at what I could have done differently. There's usually something worth learning.
But after 20 years, I've also learned that I can't be responsible for everyone else's job. I've got enough responsibility making sure I'm doing mine well.
Frequently Asked Questions: dealing with difficult real estate agents
How do you deal with a difficult real estate agent on the other side of a transaction?
Keep the focus on your client's goals rather than the other agent's behavior. Ask questions, identify the actual disagreement, and look for a practical way forward. You don't have to tolerate unprofessional behavior, but getting into a personal argument rarely helps your client.
Should a buyer's agent submit an offer if the listing agent says the seller won't accept it?
If your buyer wants to make the offer, don't let the listing agent's prediction be the deciding factor. A listing agent may have insight into the seller's expectations, but that doesn't necessarily mean they know how the seller will respond to a written offer.
What can real estate agents actually control during a transaction?
Agents can control their preparation, communication, follow-up, due diligence, and the advice they provide. They cannot control another agent's performance, a client's decisions, a lender's underwriting, or every unexpected problem that arises before closing.
How can newer real estate agents avoid taking transaction problems personally?
Start by separating what you could have prevented from what was outside your control. Review what happened, identify anything you would handle differently, and use that experience in future transactions. A difficult transaction isn't automatically evidence that you did something wrong.
Why is the relationship between cooperating real estate agents important?
Even when agents represent different clients, they still need to exchange information, coordinate deadlines, and work through disagreements. A professional relationship can make complicated transactions easier to manage. Poor communication or unnecessary conflict can create problems that have little to do with the property itself.


Comments