The Trouble With Being Sure: Lessons From Film Editing


Lessons From Film Editing: Somewhere in the editing of Raging Bull, Martin Scorsese and Thelma Schoonmaker decided that a shot worked better upside down. I'd love to know how that conversation went.
Scorsese had meticulously planned the boxing sequences, working out camera positions and storyboards before filming. He wasn't interested in making a conventional boxing movie. The fights were supposed to reflect Jake LaMotta's increasingly distorted view of the world, which explains some of the stranger things happening inside the ring.
Then Schoonmaker had to make it all work in the editing room. The final fight between LaMotta and Sugar Ray Robinson was especially complicated. Schoonmaker has described finding the rhythm of the sequence through unexpected details, including a shot of LaMotta's wife, Vickie, lowering her head into her hands and looking up again.
And somewhere in the process, they even experimented with turning a shot upside down.
I can appreciate the willingness to try that. After all the planning, shooting, and expense involved in making a movie, you're sitting in an editing room looking at the footage and somebody suggests flipping it over. At that point, you might as well see what happens.
I've edited enough video to recognize the problem, although nobody has ever asked me to edit a boxing match.
You can spend hours getting a scene exactly where you want it. You adjust the timing, move things around, and watch the same thirty seconds so many times that you can practically recite every breath. Eventually, you get it working, or at least you become convinced that you have.
Then you show it to someone who hasn't seen any of it. They don't laugh. Or worse, they laugh at something that wasn't supposed to be funny. You can explain what you were going for, which is always tempting and almost never helpful. You can insist they missed something. Or you can consider the deeply annoying possibility that the scene isn't doing what you thought it was doing.
The audience, inconveniently, hasn't been sitting next to you for the last four hours. They have no idea why you chose that particular shot or how much trouble you went through to make the transition work. They just watched it.
You remember everything that happened before the cut, including the footage that didn't make it into the finished version. You know what the scene is supposed to communicate because you've been carrying that information around in your head for days. If something isn't clear, you can't hand the viewer a copy of your editing notes and expect them to appreciate your intentions.
I've found that one of the more useful editing techniques is also one of the least impressive: stop working and go do something else. When I come back to a project the next morning, I haven't gained any new footage or developed some extraordinary new skill overnight. I've just forgotten a few of the arguments I was making to myself about why everything had to be exactly where I put it.
Sometimes I notice that a shot goes on too long. Sometimes the joke works better without the reaction I was so determined to include. Occasionally, something I spent an unreasonable amount of time fixing turns out to be unnecessary. I wonder how many perfectly good ideas get discarded because somebody has already decided how things are supposed to work. Or how many bad ones survive because everyone involved has spent too much time defending them.
I suppose there's no way to know. Which is probably a good thing, because I'd hate to have an accurate accounting of all the hours I've spent trying to save a shot that should have been cut.
Certainty can be convenient. It can also be a lousy editor.
Frequently Asked Questions: Lessons From Film Editing
Who edited Raging Bull?
Thelma Schoonmaker edited Martin Scorsese's 1980 film Raging Bull. Her work on the film earned her the Academy Award for Best Film Editing and helped establish one of cinema's most distinctive approaches to boxing sequences.
What makes the editing in Raging Bull unusual?
Rather than presenting the fights as straightforward sporting events, Raging Bull uses changes in rhythm, camera perspective, sound, and cutting to convey Jake LaMotta's psychological experience. The editing helps make each fight feel different.
Why is it helpful to take a break when editing video?
After watching the same footage repeatedly, editors can become accustomed to choices that may not work for a new viewer. Taking a break can make pacing problems, unnecessary shots, and unclear transitions easier to notice.
How do assumptions affect creative decisions?
Assumptions can cause someone to interpret new information according to what they already expect. In editing, that might mean keeping a shot because it fits the original plan, even when another approach works better.
Why is audience feedback important in video editing?
A first-time viewer doesn't have access to the editor's intentions or the footage that was removed. Their reactions can reveal confusion, pacing problems, or unintended humor that the editor no longer notices.




Comments